ETFs vs mutual funds: A complete comparison
- 4th November 2025
- 12:00 AM
- 9 min read
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are becoming more popular in India due to the growth of passive investment. However, there is still confusion – can they actually perform better than mutual funds? Understanding the difference between ETF and mutual fund is essential to creating a more effective investment portfolio, even if each offers distinct benefits.
Read this blog to understand the key differences between exchange-traded funds vs mutual funds and then evaluate which is better to invest in.
What are Exchange-Traded Funds?
An ETF is a fund that is listed on a stock market. ETF funds, like mutual funds, gather investor capital and use it to purchase a variety of assets, usually in line with a certain index, such as the BSE Sensex or the Nifty 50. ETFs, in contrast to mutual funds, are units that, like individual shares, are listed on the stock market in real time when trading is open.
As of March 2025, ETFs currently account for 13% of the mutual fund market in India, which is worth INR 65.74 lakh crore. This is almost twice as much as the 7% they held five years ago.
What are Mutual Funds?
A mutual fund is an investment vehicle which gathers the capital of several participants and invests in stocks, bonds, and money market instruments. The units that correspond to each investor’s portion of the fund’s composition are distributed to them.
The Net Asset Value (NAV) of a mutual fund is available every day. It is decided at the end of the trading day. Depending on factors like fund availability, the transaction completes at the end-of-day NAV, whether you invest in a lump sum amount or through a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP).
ETF Funds vs Mutual Funds: Key Differences
Have a look at the table below to get a clear difference between exchange-traded funds and mutual funds:
| Differences | ETFs | Mutual Fund |
| Trading And Liquidity | You can trade ETFs on the stock exchange. This makes them more liquid. | You can buy and sell mutual funds only at the end of the day at the NAV price. |
| Cost Structure | Low expense ratios | High expense ratios and management fees |
| Pricing Mechanism | Continuous pricing in market hours, based on real-time market price | End-of-the-day NAV pricing |
| Investment Approach | Since ETFs involve passive management, the fund reflects a particular index. This makes them less risky and transparent. | Since mutual funds involve active management, fund managers make investments in securities according to their analysis and forecast for the market. |
| Investment Platform | Available through a Demat or trading account | Available through asset management companies or fintech apps |
| Minimum Investment | With ETFs, investors may begin with a minimum amount. | The minimum investment required for mutual funds is usually higher. |
| Taxation | More tax-efficient since they have a lower capital gains tax | Less tax-efficient |
| Fund Type | Only passive funds that track the index | Can be active and passive |
| Diversification | ETFs provide more specialised investments that replicate a certain index. | Mutual funds provide exposure to a wider variety of securities and more opportunities for diversification. |
Types of ETFs
Now that you are aware of exchange-traded funds vs mutual funds, you need to know about their varied types. The table below comprises different types of ETFs:
-
Bond ETFs
Bond ETFs provide investors with income production and diversification by investing in fixed-income instruments, including corporate, municipal, and government bonds.
-
Equity ETFs
These exchange-traded funds (ETFs) give investors exposure to particular industries or market indexes by primarily investing in stocks of different firms.
-
Commodity ETFs
Commodity ETFs give investors exposure to commodity markets without requiring direct ownership by investing in tangible commodities such as gold, silver, oil, or agricultural products.
-
Sector ETFs
Investors can target businesses they think will outperform the overall market by using sector ETFs, which focus on certain economic sectors like technology, banking, or energy.
-
International ETFs
You can invest in the International ETFs for diversification and possible development prospects in international markets by investing in stocks or bonds of businesses. These businesses must be based outside of your home country
Types of Mutual Funds
-
Equity Funds
The primary investment of equity funds is in stocks, with the long-term goal of capital growth. They can be further categorised according to investment type, like growth, value, and mix, or market capitalisation, like large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap.
-
Debt Funds
Debt funds provide consistent income and capital preservation by investing in fixed-income assets, including corporate bonds, government bonds, and money market instruments.
-
Index Funds
By investing in the same assets in the same proportion as the index components, index funds reflect the performance of a particular market index.
-
Hybrid Funds
You can take a balanced approach to risk and return with hybrid funds. These funds distribute assets across equities and bonds.
-
ELSS Funds
You can also invest in tax-saving mutual funds, which are Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS). These funds provide both the possibility of long-term capital growth through equity investing and tax advantages under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act.
Risk Factors in ETFs and Mutual Funds
Since there are a lot of differences between exchange-traded funds vs mutual funds, both have different risk factors. The degree of risk varies depending on the underlying assets and the investor’s approach.
ETFs are not intrinsically riskier than mutual funds. Market risks like price volatility and recessions can affect both kinds of investments. However, since ETFs trade intraday, with values changing throughout the day in response to market demand, they may seem riskier. For novice investors, this feature might result in losses or impulsive trading.
As a risk-mitigation feature, mutual funds discourage frequent trading because they are valued once daily at NAV. Furthermore, actively managed mutual funds can adjust to changes in the market, which may lower risk.
On the other hand, ETFs often follow an index passively, which may not take shifting market conditions into consideration. Ultimately, the risk profile of ETFs and mutual funds depends on the underlying investments. Before investing, investors should evaluate their financial objectives and risk tolerance.
ETFs or mutual funds, where to invest?
The right choice between ETFs and mutual funds depends on your investment approach and goals.
You must invest in ETFs if you:
- Have a Demat account and have used stock broking websites before.
- Looking for inexpensive, index-based investing solutions.
- Would rather have more authority over implementation and price.
- Value trading flexibility, real-time tracking, and transparency.
On the other hand, mutual funds can be better for you if you:
- Have just started your investment journey and need a disciplined, SIP-friendly investment approach.
- Do not have a Demat account and do not want one.
- Enjoy long-term investment without worrying about market timing.
- Looking for actively managed funds that have the potential to outperform benchmark indexes in terms of returns.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the differences between exchange-traded funds vs mutual funds is crucial since both offer distinct benefits and varied risk factors. The choice between an ETF and a mutual fund is based on which best fits your investing strategy, portfolio, and profile, not on which is better. Both aim to increase wealth based on likely market returns.
You can invest in both ETFs and mutual funds through PL Capital. Once you open your Demat account for free, you get access to a range of services including derivative trading, alternative investment funds, and portfolio management services.
FAQS on ETFs vs Mutual Funds
1. What is the main difference between ETFs and mutual funds?
ETFs trade on a stock exchange in real time, like shares, while mutual funds transact at the end-of-day NAV. ETFs generally carry lower expense ratios and follow a passive investment approach, whereas mutual funds are often actively managed. The right choice depends on your investment style, cost preference, and how frequently you want to trade.
2. Which is better for beginners – ETFs or mutual funds?
Mutual funds are easier to start with. They support SIP investments, require no Demat account, and are professionally managed. ETFs are more cost-efficient with lower expense ratios but require a Demat account and basic market knowledge to trade.
3. Which is more cost-effective, ETFs or mutual funds?
Mutual funds are easier to start with, as they support SIP investments, require no Demat account, and are professionally managed. ETFs, however, are more cost-efficient. They generally carry lower expense ratios than mutual funds, making them a better option for cost-conscious investors.
4. Can I invest in both ETFs and mutual funds?
Yes, you can invest in both ETFs and mutual funds. Many investors use mutual funds for long-term, managed exposure and ETFs for low-cost, flexible trading. Holding both allows you to diversify across investment styles and cost structures within the same portfolio.
5. What are the risks of investing in ETFs vs mutual funds?
ETFs carry market volatility risk since they trade in real time, and liquidity risk if trading volumes are low. Mutual funds carry fund manager risk, where poor investment decisions can affect returns, along with higher expense ratios that eat into long-term gains. Both instruments carry market risk, but the nature of that risk differs based on how each is structured and managed.
